As the French playwright and thinker Jean Racine once claimed, “Life is a comedy to those who think, a tragedy to those who feel.” Horace Walpole echoed the sentiment, but put the two clauses in the reverse order. Whatever the order, the sentiment is one that often applies to the way fiction, not to mention drama, works. The unique thing about the work of Ludmilla Petrushevskaya is that it produces both feelings at the same time in those who read it, not the usual sense of tragicomedy, but a studied blankness of effect and affect both at the end of each of her short stories in this book, which bears the subtitle “Love Stories.” And this is not a case in which one can blame the translation, which those who know Russian claim is an adept one (by the translator Anna Summers, who has translated others of Petrushevskaya’s works as well).
I say that there is a “studied blankness of effect and affect both” because there is: the blankness of effect is contained in the continual twist which takes place at the end of each short story, where one is expecting a sense of resolution. There is in each case a sense of nothing really being resolved, but a sense of reality, of truth to real life and to the way thing actually happen, of the oftentimes inconclusive result even of big events in life. Just because so many other fictions proceed by well-worn formulas, this lack of final effect produces its own sense of surprise and shock, and often a rueful chuckle at one’s own expectations. The blankness of affect relates to the marked restraint of feeling in the narrator’s exposition of her characters and their situations: she doesn’t feel sorry for them in the conventional sense, doesn’t play sad little violin solos on her creative instrument, and doesn’t encourage the reader to feel sorry for them either.
And yet, one does feel for these characters, when all is said and done. It’s the author’s own sense of balance and discipline in dealing with the sorrowful facts of these character’s lives, with their strange and funny solutions to their predicaments, with their often unmerited suffering and undeserved rewards, which make this book the book it is. It’s as if the author took a whiny, mournful, disgruntled little series of events, and removed the vital connections of characters’ trajectories up and down in feeling and action, and instead put a laugh here, and a poignant remark there, in places where they weren’t before expected. And she doesn’t pull her punches, or bestow or waste any sympathy on her characters; such sympathy as they deserve, they may or may not get from the other characters (and in a final way from the reader, at the end of each story), but they don’t get it from the narrative voice, which is calm and full of detail and fact, but which only supplies these and insists that the reader come to his or her own conclusions. Yet, from this restrained puppeteering, there is tenderness, coming from who can say where? All one knows when reading is that Petrushevskaya is like a canny and watchful parent, who without apparent doting or pride harshly pushes her progeny forth, in such a way that she cunningly wins that doting for them from the audience, who feels for them that they have such a dragon of a progenitor that they surely deserve to be lauded and made much of by their auditors.
Even the title of this book is one which bestows that strict tone of restraint on events: the major events of that story, “there once lived a girl who seduced her sister’s husband, and he hanged himself,” are ones which are taken away from the reader who hopes to follow the path of major events. The title instead insists that there is something else of importance, and it is thus that the reader must enter the story and supply the feeling, the startlement, the connections between event and feeling. This is a book which rewards curiosity and investigation well, and which gives the reader sated by ordinary fictional motifs and sallies the charge of a lifetime. I hope you will read it soon, and discover just how original a talent Ludmilla Petrushevskaya is.
2 responses to ““Life is a comedy to those who think, a tragedy to those who feel”–Ludmilla Petrushevskaya’s “There Once Lived a Girl Who Seduced Her Sister’s Husband, and He Hanged Himself””
Ooo, now this sounds great! I love the idea of the reader not just passively investing but instead, having to bring something to the table as well. I will add it to the list, even though book purchasing is more problematic over here. One day, I shall catch up with all your choices of read.
Yes, I too would like to catch up with all YOUR choices of read, though honestly I lack the stamina to read all the heavier and more intellectual fare such as history and topics like that that you read from. This author has two other books out, also with intriguing titles like this, and I would say that any one of them would be a good read. I’ll probably post about another of them which I also have as soon as I get it read.